Day 57 of 150 Language Difficulty 7/10

Garden-path parsing follows simplest-first attachment

Quick answer

Garden-path parsing follows simplest-first attachment. Today's question (Garden-path sentences) asks about a finding from Frazier, L., & Rayner, K. in 1982. The correct option is A Minimal Attachment heuristic that prefers the simplest syntactic structure — full explanation, primary source, and glossary cross-links below.

Today's question

"The horse raced past the barn fell." Most readers stumble because they initially parse "raced" as the main verb. Frazier & Rayner (1982) attributed this to:

  1. A Working-memory failure
  2. B A Minimal Attachment heuristic that prefers the simplest syntactic structure
  3. C Lexical ambiguity in the word "raced"
  4. D Random parsing strategies
Reveal the answer and explanation

Correct: B — A Minimal Attachment heuristic that prefers the simplest syntactic structure

Frazier's garden-path model claims the parser commits incrementally to the syntactically simplest structure (Minimal Attachment, Late Closure) and only revises if forced. "The horse raced past the barn fell" is grammatical only if "raced past the barn" is read as a reduced relative clause — but the Minimal-Attachment parse treats "raced" as the main verb. Eye-movement records show readers regress to the disambiguating "fell," confirming reanalysis. Competing constraint-based models (MacDonald, Tanenhaus) treat ambiguity resolution as gradient and frequency-driven rather than serial.

About the source

Frazier, L., & Rayner, K. (1982). Making and correcting errors during sentence comprehension: Eye movements in the analysis of structurally ambiguous sentences. Cognitive Psychology, 14(2), 178–210.

Every Cognition Bible question cites a primary source — a paper, book chapter, or monograph that exists, that we can point to on Google Scholar, and whose finding the question accurately summarizes. No fabricated authority strings, no name-drops without paper-level grounding.

More from the Cognition Bible

Done with today's question? Play the FOKIQ Daily — six puzzles across six cognitive domains, free, every day.