Day 52 of 150 Logic Difficulty 8/10

Mental-model theory turns deduction into spatial inspection

Quick answer

Mental-model theory turns deduction into spatial inspection. Today's question (Mental model theory) asks about a finding from Johnson-Laird, P. N. in 1983. The correct option is Constructing concrete spatial-token models of premises and inspecting them — full explanation, primary source, and glossary cross-links below.

Today's question

Johnson-Laird's (1983) mental-model theory of deductive reasoning argues that people solve syllogisms primarily by:

  1. A Applying formal logical rules of inference
  2. B Constructing concrete spatial-token models of premises and inspecting them
  3. C Memorising previously-seen syllogisms
  4. D Random guessing
Reveal the answer and explanation

Correct: B — Constructing concrete spatial-token models of premises and inspecting them

Mental-model theory predicts that reasoning difficulty scales with the number of distinct models a premise set licenses, not with the number of formal-logic steps required. Two-model problems are reliably harder than one-model problems even when the formal derivation is the same length. The theory accounts for systematic errors — people tend to consider an initial model and miss alternatives — and is contrasted with mental-rules theories (Rips, Braine). Functional-imaging supports a parietal/spatial substrate consistent with token-manipulation accounts.

About the source

Johnson-Laird, P. N. (1983). Mental Models: Towards a Cognitive Science of Language, Inference, and Consciousness. Harvard University Press.

Every Cognition Bible question cites a primary source — a paper, book chapter, or monograph that exists, that we can point to on Google Scholar, and whose finding the question accurately summarizes. No fabricated authority strings, no name-drops without paper-level grounding.

More from the Cognition Bible

Done with today's question? Play the FOKIQ Daily — six puzzles across six cognitive domains, free, every day.